The top edge of the box looks too thin. We will create an edge to add more substance to the paper.
Select the Shape Tool (F4) and select the control points shown above in red outline. Press the Break at Points icon on the Infobar. Select the bottom portion and delete it.
Select the three remaining lines and Arrange > Convert Line to Shape. This changes the lines to closed shapes to which we can apply various flat and gradient fills.
Apply flat fills to the two outer flat shapes and apply a Linear fill to the center arc. Group all of the box objects except the shadow.
Now group all of the objects except the shadow. We’re almost done